It’s hard for us to explain the name of the winery as it is clearly something that is an inside reference. So, in the winery’s own words, “The name Mending Wall comes from the Robert Frost poem about two neighbors who meet once a year to restore the boundary that separates them, the boundary that brings them together. Our winemaking philosophy follows a similar path. Mending Wall is about coming together to explore and question the established boundaries in winemaking. Here, we’re free to experiment and play. No longer constrained by space, time or rules about what should and what should not go into a bottle.”
As to the nuts and bolts of it, this is a project/partnership between three families. The first couple you may not know even if you are a hard-core Napa fans. First is Frank Dotzler, owner of True Vineyard who later acquired Outpost Winery. Then there’s Mark Pulido and Donna Walker, who own three vineyards and produced their own Cabernet called Pulido-Walker from their Mount Veeder estate.
The third part of this story needs little introduction. He is pretty much known far and wide in the Napa by his initials alone, TRB. Thomas Rivers Brown has a hand in all the labels mentioned here and is a partner in this label. If you are one of the few who have not heard of ‘TRB’, he is the winemaker of record for a number of high profile producers on his extensive client list like Schrader, Revana, Seaver, Hestan, Aston, Round Pond, Gemstone, and Maybach, as well as his own wine, Rivers-Marie. He has accumulated a number of 100 point scores over the course of his winemaking and was Food and Wine Winemaker of the Year in 2010. Many think of him as the ‘Top Gun’ among Napa winemakers.
Simply put, you’ve got a group of passionate people, great dirt, and about as good a winemaking talent as you could hope for to put it all together. The results should be pretty predictable, and in this case they are. We don’t need to spend a lot of time talking about the current ‘marketplace’ and how pandemics and economic uncertainty make selling premium wine a bit trickier than it used to be Nor shall we introduce discussions about how this pandemic should change the nature wine distribution forever (one can only hope). Let’s just take the opportunity to enjoy labels of this caliber at, shall we say, less than standard prices. These are serious efforts.
The Mending Wall Cabernet Sauvignon Napa Valley 2014 (‘list’ $85) is only the second Cab from this who’s-who project and not a lot of folks talked about it. Also note that both of the reviews we did find were from 2016. We’ll take Robert Parker’s ‘90+’ score from four years ago with a grain of salt, and suggest that time in the bottle has pushed this one well into the ‘plus’ territory. His descriptors, however, are accurate with the exception of the ‘closed personality’. These days, there is plenty to see here.
The review, “As for the 2014 Cabernet Sauvignon, it is 100% Cabernet Sauvignon aged 20 months in 80% new French oak. It is a moderately sized cuvée of 774 cases. It is still showing some tannin and a slightly closed personality, but the wine has an impressively saturated ruby/purple color, and a burgeoning nose of blackcurrants, cedar wood, licorice and loamy soil undertones. The abundant fruit continues on the attack and midpalate, with the wine medium to full-bodied and somewhat structured. Give it another year or so of bottle age and drink it over the following 15-20.” This showy Cab, while still structured, has ripe tannins and layers of dark, complex chocolaty fruit.
We’re more on board with Galloni’s take and have the temerity to suggest that, if tasted now, both reviewers’ scores would be elevated. From Galloni, “The 2014 Cabernet Sauvignon is a big step up from the 2013. Boisterous, rich and ample, the 2014 exudes raciness from start to finish. Dark red and purplish stone fruits, mocha, spice, chocolate and new French oak give the wine its luscious, exotic personality. The 2014 is a striking wine from Mending Wall…93 points.”
The Mending Wall Petite Sirah Palisades Vineyard Napa Valley 2016 (‘list’ $55) is perhaps even more distinctive because one doesn’t find Petite Sirah performing at this level very often. But Palisades, a mile north of Calistoga, is no ordinary vineyard. A vineyard since the late 1800s, much of it replanted with original bud wood grafted onto St. George rootstock in the 70’s, it is possessed of serious fruit and the source of designations by Carlisle, Tor and Biale. It’s a historic look back into Napa history to a time when Petite Sirah was king, yet here had not only power but a certain refinement.
Antonio Galloni gave the wine an original score of 93-95 in June, 2018, then came back with a solid 95 in December with a cautionary review as follows, “The 2016 Petite Sirah Palisades Vineyard is going to need a number of years before it starts to drink well. Inky, plush and concentrated to the core, the Palisades has a lot to offer. But it is also a wine for readers who can be patient and who love Petite…” Yes it is dark as night and big, with plenty of black fruit flecked with pepper and woodsy notes, ample but refined tannins, and loads of character. But nearly two years later, we didn’t find it near as foreboding as he did. It’s a rare bird varietally and an outstanding effort. Only 193 cases produced.
Take advantage of our special pricing on these special finds at checkout.