EXCEPTIONAL ZIN TIME

We aren’t ready to make some sweeping statement about some sort of Zinfandel rennaissence. There are a number of econiomic things working against that. So we’ll just chalk it up to random chance that we have come across a surprising number of really outstanins over the last few weeks. A number of them have a really limited audiences at the $50 and up pricing that seems to baseline for many of the top producers. But we have run across that have given us hope that California’s historic varietal has a future.

Jeff Gaffner has been around the industry a long time ( for you old timers, since he started with Richard Arrowood when he was at Chateau St. Jean). He created his own label, Saxon Brown, pulling name inspiration from the Jack London novel ‘Valley of the Moon’. As the notes reporterd, “Jeff always thought that if he had a daughter, he would name her Saxon Brown after the willful heroine of Jack London’s iconic novel… In 1997, after having two sons, Jeff decided to re-purpose the name he loved for his new wine label.”

We have known Jeff for a while. He is the definition of the ‘independent winemaker’. He has very specific ideas about how things should and the talent to make very stylish wines. He has a number of side gigs as well including Stephanie by Hestan, Black Kite, and Modicum (the in house label for French Laundry).

His style is a bit more ‘old school’ and bold, but the results are usually pretty tasty. Within the context of our recent spate of memorable Zinfandels we were presented this classic, Saxon Brown Zinfandel Fighting Brothers 2018. Named tongue in cheek after his two sons, this is what the varietal can be. It’s mouthfilling with a broad presentation of brambly, dark berry fruit, spice, and a healthy but well mesh dose of sweet wood notes. ‘Big Zin’ but balanced, pure and very expressive. In other words, a Zin lover’s Zin without the rough edges.

The Wine Spectator review does it justice, “Supple and jammy, with rich and multilayered berry cobbler and toasty spice flavors that expand and flesh out on the zesty finish. Drink now through 2029…93 Points.”

The price on that Wine Spectator review was $48, an acceptable tab in the current marketplace given the performance. We’d have bought a little at that price but, $29.98, we were a lot more interested. Delicious, classic Zin.

TASTY CABERNET BUY HIDING IN PLAIN SIGHT

One of the important things a wine merchant can do is show the way. A number of folks are constantly looking for delicious deals on Cabernet. But where do they have to look? At some chain operation that’s going to tell you that whatever they have is the best deal anywhere? At the wine media where by the time you get by all of the 92-point $200 boutique Cabernets your eyes are tired? It’s tough, we know. So it’s our due diligence to mention things that should be on every Cab drinkers radar so you can’t say we didn’t tell you. The Katherine Goldschmidt Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley Stonemason Hill 2021, while a little long, is definitely a must.

Kiwi Nick Golgschmidt has been around for a long time and we have sent out a few email offers on some of his exceptional value bottlings. Starting back in 1991 as the assistant winemaker at then ‘big deal’ Simi winery, he has been and still is involved in projects all over the place (California, New Zealand, Argentina, Australia, and Spain). His own family brand is also a priority.

As the winery explains about this site, “Made in tandem by Nick and his middle daughter, Katherine, this very popular Cabernet Sauvignon has become a close family tradition over the years. The 2018 vintage marked a transition to an incredible new vineyard called Stonemason Hill. Located in Alexander Valley, this aptly-named site has large rocks leading up to a stone-walled terrace… This vineyard’s beautiful gravel loam soil with mature vines—many over thirty years old (rather rare in California thanks to phylloxera)—is ideally suited for the discerning tasters looking for an elegant drop with loads of personality and style.”

This has all of that personality with a pleasing core of black cherry, other dark fruits, and notes of spice, toffee, and a little underlying, balancing savory. It’s a straight forward, delicious mouthful of Cab with round, broad, honest fruit and pure Cabernet flavors. This is the wine all Cabernet fans should be looking for as it is everything you could ask and $21.98. How much delicious, honest Cabernet is out there for that kind of fare? Not much.

The Katherine Goldschmidt Cabernet Sauvignon Alexander Valley Stonemason Hill 202 is the answer to a lot of Cabernet questions. Yet if we don’t mention stuff like this, who will? Most of the high profile writers aren’t going to even bother with a wine like this, even though it is a personality filled, single-vineyard bottling. It’s not a ‘hot’ producer (though it’s an accomplished one), and Alexander Valley isn’t a glamor locale (except for maybe Silver Oak). If they do review it, it is upper 80s or low 90s at best because you have to save the big scores for the big boys. Now if you spend your time with a bunch of folks that have oil wells or tech companies, this might not have the cache for you. But if you like a really good bottle of Cabernet that doesn’t cost a fortune, this is that!

Here are a couple of reviews that tell the story. From James Suckling, “Coffee candies, black cherries, olives and blackberries. Quite rich and obvious, with a degree of sweetness in the full-bodied palate. Chewy, fine-grained structure. Flattering and easy to understand. Drink in 2023…90 points.”

And from Wne Enthusaist, “Tasty cocoa, blueberry and maple flavors ride a velvety texture of smooth tannins in this full-bodied, rich and lavishly oaked wine. Cedar, vanilla, clove and slight wood-char accents give it a spicy, soft allure…91 points.”

You don’t drink ‘cache’ or ‘numbers’ and this very likeable Cab, from an excellent vintage, hits all the notes for not a lot of money. That is the point.

WHAT TO LOOK FOR IN ’24

We usually like to give a detailed analysis from our perspective as to what we expect to be the most interesting categories we expect to see this year. As buyers, planning for deeper dives into certain areas is an important part of the business model. We also presume this information will help collectors make plans for their own acquisitions as well. This time around we’re going to keep it a little tighter with regards to the focus and concentrate on the biggest areas of interest.

Here at home, we’re in the middle of a fabulous, if a little bit different run on Cabernet Sauvignon. After the uncertainty of the 2020s with regard to wildfires, smoke taint, and other issues with the vintage, the prospects of 2021 are exciting. But we noted from the start that this is a little different take on Napa Cabernet, with a little lower alcohols, less bombast to the fruit, and more elegance to the overall wines. We aren’t trying to sell green edged, acidic reds as ‘food wines’. There are plenty of sommeliers to do that. The 2021s have plenty of substance and ripe fruit flavors. But they are longer, sleeker, and more refined, more resembling Bordeaux from a riper vintage than the typical bowl-you-over style we are known for.

Here’s an overview piece from Antonio Galloni that, while the message is the same, approaches it from a little different angle,  “After the brutal 2020 vintage, Napa Valley fans will be thrilled to start exploring the 2021s. The 2021s are aromatic, refined and wonderfully expressive. I found many wines to be truly exceptional both in terms of quality and what seems to be a more finessed approach than in the past, something that is evident at many estates. Vintage 2022 presented more than its fair share of challenges, so 2021 is most certainly the vintage to focus on…

“In tasting, the 2021s show tremendous energy and finesse. As noted last year, the wines share some attributes with other drought vintages, specifically 2013 and 2014. But there are some major differences, too…” These 2021s are attractive now but also have the right proportions to age nicely and, while we always manage to find good stuff, 2022 is more of a mixed bag.

On Bordeaux, your have a too-much-good-stuff scenario, which is the opposite of a problem. First you have three outstanding vintages before you, 2018, 2019, and the currently arriving 2020s. Global warming not withstanding, we can’t recall three vintages of this kind of quality in succession in the decades we have been doing this. With the exception of the 2020s, which are still rolling in, what is here is generally all there is going to be so have a good look and take the opportunity to augment your cellar…or start one. The 2021s by and large aren’t earth shattering, but the reviews are out on the 2022 futures and it is a vintage that also has some gems.

The Wine Advocate review on the 2022 Bordeaux will give you the perspective, “At its best, this is a vintage of remarkable concentration, energy and harmony; but far from forgiving mistakes, 2022 punished them, and the less-successful wines are jammy, astringent and rustic. And where sunny vintages such as 2018 sometimes efface differences between sites and styles, 2022 has thrown them into heightened relief. This is true at every level of the hierarchy, and terroirs conventionally thought to be of only modest potential were also capable of delivering brilliant results this year…” Lots of options with Bordeaux.

Burgundy as well offers lovely options among the 2019s and 2020s that are on hand though there are still a few things on the market that will show up a little later. The 2021 whites are exciting while we are being selective with the 2021 reds. For the most part the ’21 red are ‘like Burgundies of old’ in that they are sleeker and less ample but crisp and elegant. Most don’t possess the punch of the other vintages we mentioned.

We have had our first arrivals of the 2022s which, thus far, look like a suppler version of the 2015s which means they will be flattering early on and, hopefully because the vintage was generous volume-wise, prices will be mediated to some extent. Juicy, plump Pinot Noir is always welcome.

Here’s a snippet that tells the story, “Generous yields brought respite from the relative traumas of high temperatures, dry conditions, devastating frosts and regrettably empty cellars of recent vintages – and then there’s the quality of the wines too. For most vignerons, 2022 was a gift.  The best Pinot Noir this year is joyous. Fresh and vibrant, with ripe yet crunchy fruit, incredibly fine but present tannin structure, moderate alcohols, and often with a saline, savoury or bitter edge: these are modern, climate-change era wines, yet remain classically proportioned.

“The 2022s are almost irresistible from barrel, many of them so juicy and delicious that they are quite frankly hard to spit out. But don’t let their approachability fool you into thinking they won’t age, for everything is there in the best wines. As Jean-Marie Fourrier noted, they’re the sort of wines that are so good young that you will likely regret drinking them so early.” More good Burgundy? Yes, please.

The 2021 Pinot Noirs from both California and Oregon are special, with plenty of bright fruit and a lifted demeanor. The 2022s are a bit more of a mixed scenario so playing the ‘bird in the hand’ in this category is the smart move.

Times are promising in Italy with 2019, 2020, and 2021 in the prime northern regions all offering exciting options but relative to each vintage’s differing profiles. There are 2019 Barolos on hand as well as expectations for 2020 Barbarescos and 2019 Brunellos in the first half of the year. As a heads up, though there hasn’t been a lot written so far, but we are very excited about the 2021 vintage in both Piedmont and Tuscany based on the ‘little’ wines we have tasted so far.

Those are the ‘biggest’ topics as we see them. As always there will be plenty of stuff going on and our expectations is that we will find a number of exciting things from the usual suspects (Spain, South America, New Zealand, Australia, et. al) as viticulture, winemaking, and logistics continue to improve and, for the most part, generally good weather and fewer (though more violent) climate quirks provide overall better results for wine overall. Don’t be surprised if you see some things from less familiar places like South Africa, Greece, and Georgia (the country not the state) as they continue to spread their wings. As always, we will be there to filter out the chaff and provide the best wines and the best deals out there. Happy 2024.