PINK II: ROSE REPORT

Truth be told, I wasn’t enthusiastic about 2020 as a rose vintage early on. Somehow they didn’t seem to possess the meat or the moxie of the better vintages. As time has passed, however, they have come together and gained depth beyond expectations.

The tariffs caused things to got off to a late start on imported rosés, and the subsequent shipping backlog has delayed arrivals even further not only to us, but to the reviewers as well. So there aren’t a lot of notes out there right now on pink wines, but we suspect they’ll be along. But we found plenty of tasty things to present so enjoy…

Chateau de Pampelonne Cotes de Provence 2020-We’ve had the Cotes de Provence in the lineup several times over the last couple of decades. It is the exemplary version of Provence rose, bright, fresh, versatile and well priced (that last one is particularly relevant). This vineyard, with a view of the Mediterranean, was first planted after World War I and the estate dates back to the mid-1800s. The blend here is 40% Grenache, 30% Cinsualt, 20% Syrah and 10% the unique, historic grape Tibouren.

Maybe it was just a good day, but this one struck us as one of the more engaging efforts from this historic chateau. The traditional red berry fruit is the central theme but floral notes, orange, and a little salinity all make their presence felt in the bright, appealing blend. A crowd-pleasing choice for under $20.

La Remise de Morderee Vin de France 2020 – We’ve got our Mordoree two ways this time around. The La Remise de Mordoree Rose 2020 has that classic Mordoree style but a different profile because of the unusual combination of grapes here, 40% Grenache, 30% Marselan (Marselan is a cross between Cabernet Sauvignon and Grenache), and 30% Merlot. That is also why it is labelled ‘vin de France’ as some of the grapes aren’t ‘recognized’ for the appellation. In any case, it is a perfectly delightful pink wine, the unique varietals giving the wine a bit more drive to play against some lighter meat dishes (though it’s perfectly fine as an aperitif), and the $15 fare giving you a rather modest entry fee into the highly respected wines of Mordoree.

It’s from 20-year-old vines planted in sand with some clay and, for the record, hand-harvested, destemmed, direct pressed and estate-bottled. Red berries, maybe a little blood orange, some peppery notes, and a lifted, citrusy finish make for an interesting ‘value’ entrant from a top house.

Domaine de la Morderee Cotes-du-Rhone Rose La Dame Rousse 2020-Always a favorite around here, we select different offerings from among their roses every year but there is always Mordoree on the shelf. The Dame Rousse Cotes du Rhone is the traditional ‘workhorse’ of their rose lineup (they make five) and not far behind their Tavel qualitatively and in under $20 as well (the Tavels are $35-45 these days). Grenache leads the blend at 40% with the rest 35% Syrah, 15% Cinsault, 5% Carignan, and 5% Mourvedre farmed organically and harvested from a variety of terroirs.

A little more weight and density here, with strawberry and red melon the main thrust of the flavors with blood orange, floral aromas, savory herbs and some mineral notes. While this is a great producer on several levels, their pinks are definitely ‘blue chips’ of the category.

Bonny Doon Vineyard Vin Gris de Cigare 2020– We have tasted and sold many vintages of this over the years, but this one struck us as a cut above many of the recent renditions. The blend, from five different Central Coast AVAs, seems scattered but the wine is anything but. The mix is 71% Grenache, 11% Cinsault, 5% Clairette, 5% Grenache Blanc, 4% Mourvedre, and 4% Vermentino and the interplay of this wide varietal range presents juxtaposing impressions of berries, white stone fruit, and citrus with accents of savory spice. This is California rose with a definite French accent that comes together in an appealing way, with an engaging juicy core and snappy highlights. A high point in this series, it shows Randall Grahm still takes the project seriously.

Unlike a lot of Euro pinks that were, until recently, stuck on boats, this one has a nice review from Josh Reynolds at Vinous, “Light, shimmering orange. Fresh red berry and citrus fruit aromas are complemented by suggestions of candied rose and pungent herbs. Silky and open-knit, showing good depth to the raspberry, cherry and bitter orange pith flavors. Tightens up slowly on a long, spice-inflected finish that leaves a gently sweet red fruit note behind…90 points.”

Domaine La Roncalier Tavel Rose 2020– Typically one of the better values among the now trendy Tavels, the 2020 La Rocaliere is a great representation of the concentrated, punchy style that caused people to take notice of it in the first place. The estate, which dates back to 1995 owns 20 ha in both Tavel and Lirac. The Tavel holdings traverse three different terroirs, those differences adding complexity to the blend of 60% Grenache, 30% Cinsault, and 10% Syrah.

One of the deeper colored ‘pinks’ on the shelf (leaning towards ruby), the visual gives you notice that this will be a more substantial rose in the glass. Weighty and fresh at the same time, there’s abundant cherry and strawberry fruit laced with a stony minerality and violet notes.

Los Arrotos del Pendon Leon 2020– Yeah, we know we have complained that it seems everybody is trying to get into the action with rose. But when someone as accomplished as Raul Perez does it, you have to pay attention. Of course, it is a rose born of Raul’s singular vision. It’s from 100% Prieto Picudo from very old vines in stony clay at high-altitude (over 2500 ft above seal level). Macerated for two days on the skins before bleeding off, fermented with only indigenous yeasts in stainless steel, raised on the fine lees for four months in tank, then bottled without fining or filtration, it’s the kind of outside-the-box creation one expects from Perez.

So where’s Leon? Everywhere, it seems. It’s a huge area that stretches across northwestern Spain from Rioja to the Portuguese border and most of the way from Madrid to the north and includes Ribera del Duero and Toro. So it’s anybody’s guess where Raul found this vineyard of old Prieto Picudo. Preito Picudo is indigenous to the region and relatively rare and yields darkly colored reds.

This wine itself is reminiscent of a wine we sold years ago from Australia from Charles Melton. It is unapologetically dark rose, probably better described as ‘light red’ rather than ‘pink’. It has a rich center and weighty feel for a rosé but there is sneaky, well-embedded acidity to give it the necessary lift. This wants to be red wine and the flavors are more vinous than most in the category, yet the texture is smooth and slippery. Dark melon, mulberry, restrained minerality and a hint of wild herb, this is a substantial and delicious addition to the lineup this year. Of course we have come to expect that sort of thing from Raul.

AN ALBARINO STORY

*This is a little unusual for us, but something we might start doing a little more often.  In the course of our ongoing research to support the emails and writeups we do, we try to include as much information as we can without every article looking like “War & Peace” or something ‘Micheneresque’.  Occasionally we do run a across a story done by somebody else that has great information or teaches a lot about some aspect of the world of wine.  We are of a mind to publish them for your consideration.

This article was written for the importer for Raul Perez’ new Albariño project (Atalier) by Andrew Mulligan, the Spanish portfolio manager for the company.  Naturally, it is a bit of a sales pitch but we thought the history aspects, etc. are pretty cool here.  Yeah, it’s geeky stuff, but pretty informative.    We’re going to do a more concise email offering on this outstanding new Albariño moving forward.  But we couldn’t possibly include this much detail and this is an article that few consumers would ever find, or even know to look for.

=========================AN ALBARINO STORY (Andrew Mulligan)

We are very pleased to announce the arrival of the 2017 vintage of ‘A Cruz das Ánimas’, the Albariño from Atalier by Raúl Pérez. While this is the second vintage produced under this label, it should be considered the first vintage in which the vision of the project has been fully realized. The 2016, while terrific, was cobbled together from myriad sources, whereas the 2017 comes from three dedicated coastal sites that were specifically chosen to carry the project into the future.

The Rías Baixas is an unusual appellation in that it is not geographically contiguous. In the north, around the town of Cambados, there is the Val do Salnés sub-zone. In the south, along the Miño River (which forms the natural border with Portugal), are O Rosal and Condado do Tea. Less well-known and more recently established are Soutomaior, located between Pontevedra and Vigo, and Ribeira de Ulla, which lies to the south of Santiago de Compostela.

In the past, there was a tremendous amount of varietal diversity in the region. Indeed, there are twelve authorized varieties in the appellation – a half dozen each of white and red. Since the establishment of the D.O. in 1988, however, Albariño has risen to near complete dominance, now accounting for 96% of the planted acreage.

The origins of Albariño are not universally agreed upon, either by ampelographers or winegrowers. Some believe that the variety is native to this corner of the Iberian Peninsula (insomuch as any grape can be considered truly “native” to Western Europe). Others believe that it was brought over by French monks in the 11th and 12th centuries via the Camino de Santiago. Still others believe its origins to be Germanic. “Alba” is a Latinate root for “white” and ”Rin” is the Rhine River, so it’s possible to interpret the name Albariño as “White of the Rhine”.

Wherever it came from originally, there is no dispute as to Albariño’s ancestral home in Spain: the Val do Salnés. The southern zones of the appellation were historically planted more to red varieties like Caiño Tinto, Loureiro Tinto and Espadeiro, and white varieties like Caiño Blanco, Treixadura and Loureiro Blanco (the latter two of which are still widely planted just over the border in Portugal), but the vast majority of those plantations were pulled up to make way for Albariño over the last three to four decades. With very few exceptions, Albariño vineyards that are referred to as “old” in Condado do Tea or O Rosal top out around 35-40 years of age. In Val do Salnés, however, it is still possible to find some very old parcels. Owing to the predominance of sandy soils in the coastal areas, there are even some plots that survived the phylloxera crisis of the late 19th century, thus making them some of the oldest un-grafted vitis vinifera plantings in the world. The 2017 Atalier comes from a trio of such vineyards, all within a kilometer of the coast in the village of Dena.

These 150-year-old Albariño vines are trained in the traditional pergola style.  Rodri Méndez, the unofficial conservationist-in-chief of the Salnés Valley, is the person responsible for scouting the vineyards and establishing the agreements with the owners, whom he has known all his life. Rodri’s bonafides are rock solid: he’s a member of the family that founded Do Ferreiro, one of the first commercial wine brands in the Rías Baixas. Its founding pre-dates the formal establishment of the D.O. by at least fifteen years, and it remains a reference point domaine, not just in the Rías Baixas, but in all of Galicia. Rodri has since split off to launch his own projects, but he remains almost religiously committed to seeking out, recuperating and preserving historic sites such as the ones that go into Atalier. You see, old vines are not very sought after in this new world of commodified Albariño. Most folks these days want to farm for kilos, and old vines are notoriously miserly with their yields. Almost every year, parcels of un-grafted, pre-phylloxera Albariño vines are either abandoned by people of advanced age or plowed under to make way for new plantations. My colleague Max and I got to visit the largest of the three sites this past month, and it was, without a doubt, one of the most moving vineyard visits of my career. I have certainly visited more visually arresting sites: Knights Valley in the shadow of Mt. St. Helena; the bleached and blasted moonscape of Santorini; the vertiginous slopes of Amandi in the Ribeira Sacra. But this visit was different. The vineyard lies exactly at sea level and is totally flat, so there’s no real drama to the landscape. It was what this site represents that was at once both inspiring and poignant.

Vicente has worked this plot his entire life.  We didn’t ask Vicente, the vineyard’s owner, his exact age, but I’m guessing he lands somewhere between 80 and 90 years old. He has looked after this vineyard for his entire life, like his father and grandfather before him. Though he’s not entirely sure, he surmises that the vineyard was planted before his grandfather was born. Rodri Méndez estimates that the Albariño vines are somewhere around 150-160 years old on average, based on the breadth of the trunks and the paucity of the yield. There is at least one vine on the property that is an order of magnitude older than that: a single Caiño Tinto vine with a trunk as wide as a dogwood’s and limbs that extend far and wide enough over its trellis to provide shade for a large patio. Vicente’s children chose other vocations, leaving him without any heirs to carry on the family tradition of cultivating the vine, so Rodri now takes responsibility for the vineyard management and pays him for the agreed-upon share of the grapes at harvest. Vicente keeps a small portion of the yield to make a wine for home consumption.

Rodri and Marcial Dorado, another scion of an old northwest Iberian vine-growing family, accompanied Max and I for the visit. Though it was immediately obvious to us Americans, they still took great pains to emphasize how special a site this was. “This is the real thing, Andrew! This is the way of our ancestors! Look at this! Look at it!” Their inarticulate exhortations were fitting for the moment. Anyone who works in this business long enough will eventually become at least slightly desensitized to the wonder that a visit to a vineyard can occasion. Some will become downright cynical. But while we’ll never get back to the state of mind we enjoyed on those early trips, when we were seeing everything for the first time, we are still occasionally privileged to feel that wonder break through again.

“When these vines were planted,” I thought to myself, “My mother’s ancestors were breeding horses for the Polish cavalry and my father’s ancestors were being greeted in America by NINA signs.” How much has changed for my family since then! And how little has changed for Vicente’s. These vines we were walking amongst – after all these years, with their famines and diseases and wars and scourges; their marriages and births and innovations and poems and songs – they would still produce fruit! And my friend Raúl would turn that fruit into wine, and my other friends and I would get to sell that wine to yet other friends, and those friends would sell it to friends and strangers alike…when you take the time to reflect on it, this is remarkable!

With raw material like this, there’s not really much to do but stay out of the way, and despite the abundance of accolades Raúl and his wines have received, staying out of the way is probably the thing he does best. There are two key decisions, however, that affected the way the wine came to show the character it does. The first concerns malic acid. There are certainly counterexamples, but the vast majority of Albariño on the market goes through at least partial malolactic conversion. The grapes have a very high level of naturally-occurring malic acid, so when picked at the usual time, they need a little bit of that conversion to avoid coming out shrill. Raúl, however, eschews malolactic in Albariño. In order to naturally lower the malic acid levels in the grapes and obviate the need for even partial conversion, he waits to harvest for as long as two or three weeks after most everyone in the zone has finished. This is not so much time that the grapes raisinate or arrive at unreasonable levels of potential alcohol (the finished wine is around 12.8% or 13%), but their malic acid levels do drop considerably. Raúl and Rodri like to say that they pick on the same day every year: “The day before it rains.”

The other decision is to elaborate the wine in oak, standard practice for all the wines – white and red – that Raúl produces. These days, oak fermentation and aging are often disparaged out of hand as “modern” techniques, representing what the great Robert Haas would call “some tragic falling off from a first world / of undivided light” – some ideal of purity that is almost entirely apocryphal. This is especially true for white varieties that are expected to be made in a fresh, reductive style. But as with any polarizing issue in the wine world – sulfur comes to mind – context is of paramount importance. Putting Albariño into a new French 225L HT and racking it after six months into another one is modern (and sounds gross). Putting Albariño into large, used foudres to stimulate oxygen exchange during élevage is something that’s been done for generations. The style we think of now when we think of Albariño – fresh, easy, fruity – is actually quite new. The first stainless steel tanks didn’t arrive to the region until the 1980s! The prevalence of reductively raised Albariños in the market these days is almost purely a function of economics: stainless steel élevages save time, money and labor – simple as that. And the commodification of Albariño wines over the last twenty or thirty years has led to a philosophy of “pick, crush, ferment, bottle, sell” that has all but relegated this noble variety to the “cheap and cheerful” bin along with Verdejo.

The 2017 ‘A Cruz das Ánimas’ from Atalier by Raúl Pérez is an example of the ecstatic heights that old-vine Albariño can reach when treated with the respect, care, and patience it deserves. It is also is something that is becoming vanishingly rare in the world of wine today. Sites like these represent an ever more endangered piece of the cultural patrimony of Galicia. When I speak of the poignancy of visiting a site like this, it’s not simply about un-grafted vines. Apart from the vines themselves, it’s the tradition of passing jealously guarded parcels of land from generation to generation that is becoming increasingly difficult to sustain in the new global economy. A wine like this provides us with an opportunity to partake of this legacy and play a part in keeping what’s left of it alive.

 

 

 

 

RAUL PEREZ ULTREIA 2016-ANOTHER SUPER VALUE EFFORT

We’ve been telling the Raul Perez story for a while now.  If you haven’t heard it, think of it as one of those ‘local guy makes good’ as long as that locale is northwestern Spain.  The Raul Perez ‘legend’ has grown over the years and, thanks to some ‘market changes’, the prices have come down a bit.  Meanwhile Raul is making some of the best wines he has ever made.  If it all sounds like a pretty advantageous situation for consumers, it is!

While his portfolio is chock full of stunning examples made from the native grape of Bierzo, Mencia, some difficult to tell apart because the label nomenclature is so similar, we have chosen to focus on his entry-level bottling called Ultreia.  Why?  Well it might be one of the most amazing red wine values in Spain, if not the world.

Raul has been working at a high level for quite a while now and certainly the raw materials play a part in the wine’s success. The Mencia grapes for this cuvee are grown in clay soils in the village of Valtuille de Abajo and were harvested from vines that were planted between 1900 and 1940. The Raul Perez Bierzo Ultreia St. Jacques 2015, which we sold last year, was the wine that gave Raul a spotlight like none of his previous, brilliant efforts ever had.

The 2015 vintage was perfect for Raul’s style. The flavors ranged from ripe cranberry to dark cherry. Weight-wise this Mencia plays like a hefty Pinot from the Santa Lucia Highlands flavor-wise, but with more florality to the nose, more lift and freshness to the palate, and striking harmony. Sometimes Mencia can be a little inward and unyielding at first, but there is none of that here! This is a beautifully proportioned and surprisingly sophisticated red for the fare.

It got plenty of attention from the critics including 93 points from Luis Gutierrez of Wine Advocate with comments, “…The 2015 Ultreia St Jacques …is amazingly good for the price. Produced from old vines, this is a serious wine, with juicy fruit, a fine palate and good freshness…”.  James Suckling tossed a 91 on that ’15 saying, ” …Cherry and floral accents sing through the finish. Energetic…”

We finished our comments on that at the time by saying, “We are sure there are more reviews to come but we suspect they will arrive a little late.”  Sure enough, the Wine Spectator came along and not only gave it a 91 point score but included it in the Wine Spectator Top 100 (#51) for 2017.

We’re reminding you of all of that to tell you this.  The Raul Perez Bierzo Ultreia St. Jacques 2016 just hit the floor and it is another striking effort.  Plenty of explosive red and black fruits in the mid-palate, maybe a touch less fleshy at the moment but with tremendous drive through the back palate, this is quite aristocratic for something in this price range.    We’re finding that 2016 is making its own mark in Spain as a vintage.

Once again the wine features mostly Mencia, with touches of other indigenous varietals Bastardo (Trousseau) and Garnacha Tintorera (Alicante Bouschet).  This wine was done via 80% whole cluster fermentation in large oak vats then aged in a variety of vessels from 225L and 500L barrels to upright vats to cement. It is bottled unfiltered and unfined.  Expressive and attention-getting, with a slightly cooler edge, it is once again an incredibly impressive beverage for a modest fare comfortably under $20 ($17.98).

We haven’t seen any press yet (3/12/2018) but given the performance here, and Raul’s recent track record, we are pretty confident there will be plenty.  We love the stuff.  Meanwhile we have ours, get yours.